Authenticity Report

ISSUE #106

This week: we're looking at Apple. Fifty years after its founding, it remains one of the world's most influential brands and ranks #5 in our Authenticity 500 Index.

In this issue:

  • Why only 27% of Apple voters rank it their most authentic brand

  • What the iPhone Duo and Apple's new holiday film say about how it tells stories

  • Carhartt's $1 million commitment to feeding families, plus Vans and In-N-Out

| THE REPORT

Apple: More Than the Products We Use

Why only 27% of Apple voters rank it first.

It's hard to believe Apple turned 50 this year. I remember when owning a Mac meant you were a little different from everyone else. Today, Apple products are everywhere, and most of us probably don't give much thought to how often we use them.

Think about how many times you reach for your phone during the day. To take a photo, find a restaurant, get directions or check in with someone. Apple didn't invent any of those things, but it made them so convenient that they've become second nature.

And that's what interests me about Apple. We depend on its products, but does that necessarily mean we feel connected to the brand?

In our latest Authenticity 500, Apple ranks #5, with a People's Vote Score of 51.8 out of 100.

#5 Overall rank, down from #3 in 2025

51.8 People’s Vote Score (of 100)

27.1% of Apple voters ranked it their most authentic brand

That last number caught my attention. Among respondents who selected Apple, only 27.1% ranked it first. That raises an interesting question. Has Apple become so familiar that some of the personal connection has faded?

Two comments from our community stood out:

❝

It's clean and true to what it does. You know what Apple is and what it stands for. Something clean, modern, and great quality.

— John S.
❝

Consistency across how they communicate and their products and experiences.

— Tom K.

Both respondents point to something Apple has been good at for decades: consistency. You know what you're getting, whether it's the design, the experience or how the company presents itself.

I've always appreciated how easily Apple products work together. Something as simple as moving a photo from an iPhone to a MacBook takes almost no effort. It's one of those conveniences you get used to and would probably miss if it disappeared.

The new iPhone Duo, Apple's first foldable phone, is an interesting test of that approach. It went on sale in October, and CEO John Ternus took a shot at competing devices, saying they "feel like two phones awkwardly stuck together."

I'm not convinced I need a folding phone, but I'm curious to see whether Apple can make it feel useful enough that people eventually wonder how they managed without one.

Apple's advertising is another reason the brand has remained so recognizable. Its Shot on iPhone campaign has spent years showing what people create rather than focusing entirely on camera specifications.

Its new holiday film, The Dreamer, follows a young artist whose parents encourage him to keep drawing. A MacBook Neo helps him bring his drawings to life, but the film is really about his family and their belief in him.

I thought it was a good example of Apple telling a story without making the product the center of attention.

Steve Jobs described this approach back in 2011:

❝

It's technology married with liberal arts, married with the humanities, that yields us the results that make our heart sing.

— Steve Jobs

Of course, Apple doesn't always live up to its reputation. The continued delays with its AI-powered Siri improvements are a good example. For a company known for making technology easy to use, it's frustrating when a promised upgrade to something as basic as a voice assistant keeps slipping.

And when customers are paying a premium, those expectations are even higher.

Apple has spent decades earning people's trust. I think the challenge now is finding new ways to earn their enthusiasm.

There's a difference between a product you rely on and a brand you genuinely care about. It'll be interesting to see how Apple navigates that over the next 50 years.

| THE TAKEAWAYS

What Apple Teaches Us

1. Make the experience the difference. Great design gets noticed. A product that makes everyday things easier gets used and remembered.

2. Become part of people's habits. Apple didn't invent photos, maps or video. It made them part of how we live.

3. Sell the possibility. When people can see what they'll make with a product, the specifications matter a lot less.

| IN ACTION: THIS WEEK’S STANDOUTS

Carhartt x Feeding America x Farmlink

Carhartt committed $1 million to The Farmlink Project and Feeding America. The Feeding America half alone will provide 5 million meals through its food bank network. Its team will also help distribute food around Detroit ahead of Thanksgiving.

For a workwear brand built around the people who keep things moving, this is a cause connected to the people it serves.

ALSO WORTH YOUR ATTENTION

Vans and In-N-Out Burger released a limited-edition Classic Slip-On, bringing together two brands with deep roots in Southern California culture. Net proceeds support the HIS EYES Foundation, giving a familiar collaboration a purpose beyond the product.

| FREE RESOURCES

Why I Created the Personal Authenticity Journal

We spend a lot of time talking about whether brands are authentic. I wanted to turn that same question toward ourselves.

The Personal Authenticity Deep-Dive Journal grew out of a simple idea: understanding what matters to us is just as important as understanding what we believe about the brands we choose.

It's a guided space to reflect on your values, the influences behind your decisions, and whether the way you're living lines up with what you believe.

It's not a test, and there are no right or wrong answers. The goal is to help you recognize patterns, better understand yourself and get clearer about what you want to keep or change.

I hope it gives you a little time to think about something we don't always make enough room for: being yourself.

| FROM PAST ISSUES

Thanks for reading Authenticity Report.
Stories, research, and perspectives on the brands and people shaping authenticity.

What makes a brand feel like yours? Reply to this email or write to [email protected]. I read the replies, and we may feature yours next week.

Disclosure: Some content in this newsletter may be generated with the assistance of AI tools for research and drafting. It is reviewed, edited, and fact-checked by our editorial team before publication.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate